LootList

Beauty / Reviews

Beauty review roundup

The best brow pencils, in plain English

A good brow pencil fills sparse spots so brows look full and even. We read editor tests and boiled them down: which pencils draw natural strokes, which fill in fast, and which last.

  • Last reviewed October 19, 2026
  • 3 brow pencils
  • 2 expert reviews read

We didn't test these ourselves. We read reviews from experts who test products hands-on, then summed up where they agree and where they don't. Every source is linked. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Short on time? Start here

Our top pick in each group. Tap one to jump to the details.

Best overall Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz $23–$27 An ultra-fine tip for natural, hair-like strokes. See details Best for filling in fast Kosas Brow Pop Dual-Action Defining Pencil $22–$26 A slanted tip and lots of shades. See details Best sweat-resistant REFY Brow Pencil $18–$22 A fine tip that stays put. See details

Before you buy: 3 quick checks

Shade first, then tip.

Match the shade

Pick a shade that matches the brow hair, or one shade lighter. Too dark looks harsh. Taupe often suits blondes, and soft black or dark brown suits very dark hair.

Fine tip or slanted tip

Ultra-fine tips draw tiny hair-like strokes for a natural look. Wider, slanted tips fill in faster and are often easier for beginners.

Brush it out

Use short, light strokes in the direction the hair grows, then brush through with the spoolie (the small brow brush on the other end) to soften the color.

Compare at a glance

On a phone, swipe the table sideways to see every column.

PencilBest forTypical priceTipLook
1. Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz Best overall $23–$27Ultra-fineNatural, hair-like strokes
2. Kosas Brow Pop Dual-Action Defining Pencil Best for filling in fast $22–$26SlantedSoft, defined brows
3. REFY Brow Pencil Best sweat-resistant $18–$22Ultra-fineSubtle, precise definition

The 3 best brow pencils, explained

Best overall first. Prices are typical ranges, not live prices, so check Amazon for today's price.

#1Best overallPick a shade

Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Wiz

  • Ultra-fine
  • Natural, hair-like strokes
  • Spoolie on the other end

$23–$27typical price

An ultra-fine tip for natural, hair-like strokes. Marie Claire names it the best brow pencil overall, and Who What Wear picks it as the best for drawing hair strokes.

Comes in shades. Pick the one that matches the wearer's brow hair on the listing. For a gift, ask their shade first or choose a pick that doesn't need one.

What testers liked

  • A super-slim tip that draws strokes like real brow hairs.
  • Smooth and well pigmented.
  • Comes with a spoolie to soften the color.

Common complaints

  • Doesn't last as long as waterproof pencils.
  • Pricier, and better for natural brows than bold, statement brows.

Skip it if: They want bold, filled-in brows fast. Kosas Brow Pop (#2) has a wider, slanted tip.

See it on Amazon
Read the reviews (2)

Summed up from Marie Claire, Who What Wear.

#2Best for filling in fastPick a shade

Kosas Brow Pop Dual-Action Defining Pencil

  • Slanted
  • Soft, defined brows
  • Wide shade range

$22–$26typical price

A slanted tip that fills brows in quickly. Marie Claire picks it for bold brows, and Who What Wear names it the best brow pencil for shade range.

Comes in shades. Pick the one that matches the wearer's brow hair on the listing. For a gift, ask their shade first or choose a pick that doesn't need one.

What testers liked

  • A slanted tip that's easy to blend.
  • Lots of shades.
  • Natural-looking definition that doesn't smudge.

Common complaints

  • Softer than a classic pencil, so it's less precise.

Testers disagree on: The texture. Who What Wear found it nourishing. Marie Claire found it a bit dry going on.

Skip it if: They want tiny, hair-like strokes. ABH Brow Wiz (#1) has a finer tip.

See it on Amazon
Read the reviews (2)

Summed up from Marie Claire, Who What Wear.

#3Best sweat-resistantPick a shade

REFY Brow Pencil

  • Ultra-fine
  • Subtle, precise definition
  • Sweat-resistant

$18–$22typical price

A fine tip that stays put. Marie Claire names it the best water-resistant brow pencil, and Who What Wear picks it for precision.

Comes in shades. Pick the one that matches the wearer's brow hair on the listing. For a gift, ask their shade first or choose a pick that doesn't need one.

What testers liked

  • An ultra-fine tip for precise strokes.
  • Resists sweat.
  • Good color payoff.

Common complaints

  • Only a few shades.
  • Not for dramatic, bold brows.

Skip it if: Their brow color is hard to match. Kosas Brow Pop (#2) has more shades.

See it on Amazon
Read the reviews (2)

Summed up from Marie Claire, Who What Wear.

How we pick

More beauty reviews